Global Trade and Investment (International Business Unit-II, MBA) Pokhara University PU Trimester

Global Trade and Investment (Unit II)

2.1 Global and regional economic integration & its impact on Nepalese economy (WTO, BIMSTEC, SAFTA)

Regional economic integration refers to agreements among countries in a geographic region to reduce and ultimately remove tariff and non-tariff barriers to the free flow of goods, services, and factors of production among each other. The ultimate goal is to enhance productivity and achieve greater economic interdependence.

In simple terms, regional economic integration refers to agreements among countries in a geographic region to reduce and remove trade barriers to the free flow of goods, services, and factors of production among each other

Features of Regional Economic Integration:

• Removal of Trade Barriers: Elimination or reduction of tariffs, quotas, and other trade restrictions among member countries.
• Enhanced Productivity: By specializing in goods and services where they have a comparative advantage, member countries can increase overall productivity.
• Greater Economic Interdependence: Increased trade, investment, and movement of people and capital lead to deeper economic ties.
• Improved Market Efficiency: Larger markets provide economies of scale and encourage competition, leading to more efficient resource allocation.
• Shared Costs of Public Goods/Infrastructure: Countries can cooperate on large-scale projects like transport and energy infrastructure, sharing the financial burden.
• Policy Coordination: Member states often align policies in areas such as trade, investment, finance, and even social and environmental regulations.
• Building Block for Global Integration: Regional agreements can serve as stepping stones towards broader multilateral trade liberalization.
• Non-Economic Can foster peace, security, and political stability among member states.

Examples of Regional Economic Integration:

• European Union (EU): A highly integrated economic and political union. The EU is an economic and political union of 27 member states located primarily in Europe.
• North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) / USMCA: A free trade area between the US, Canada, and Mexico.
• ASEAN Free Trade Area (AFTA): A free trade area among Southeast Asian nations.
• South Asian Free Trade Area (SAFTA): SAFTA is a free trade agreement among the member states of the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC). It aims to reduce tariffs and non-tariff barriers to trade within the SAARC region. SAFTA and Nepal: Time for paradigm shift - The Himalayan Times - Nepal's No.1 English Daily Newspaper | Nepal News, Latest Politics, Business, World, Sports, Entertainment, Travel, Life Style News
• Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation (BIMSTEC): A regional organization focusing on technical and economic cooperation. BIMSTEC is a regional organization comprising seven member states lying around the Bay of Bengal littoral and contiguous areas. These seven nations are: Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Thailand.

Types of Major Regional Economic Integration:

Regional economic integration occurs in various forms, representing different levels of commitment and integration:

1.      Free Trade Area (FTA):

o     Member countries eliminate all tariffs and non-tariff barriers on trade among themselves. However, each member maintains its own independent trade policies with non-member countries.

o     NAFTA (now USMCA), ASEAN Free Trade Area (AFTA).

2.      Customs Union:

o     Builds upon a Free Trade Area by adding a common external tariff (CET) on imports from non-member countries. This means all members apply the same tariffs to goods imported from outside the union.

o     MERCOSUR.

3.      Common Market:

o     Extends a Customs Union by allowing the free movement of factors of production (labor, capital) among member countries, in addition to goods and services.

o     East African Community (EAC).

4.      Economic Union:

o     The most comprehensive form of economic integration, integrating a common market with the coordination of national economic policies (monetary policy, fiscal policy, social policy).

o     European Union (EU) is the most prominent example, though not all members have fully integrated monetary policy (Eurozone).

5.      Political Union:

o     Involves complete political as well as economic integration, leading to a common government and unified policies. This is the ultimate stage of integration, often involving a loss of national sovereignty.

o     While rare in practice among independent nations, historical examples or federations within a country can be seen as approximations.

Why would a country join regional economic integration?

1. Expansion of Trade Opportunities

Regional integration removes or reduces tariffs, quotas, and trade barriers among member countries, making it easier and cheaper to trade.

Countries can increase exports, access larger consumer markets, and benefit from comparative advantages.

2. Attraction of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI)

Investors prefer regions with stable trade environments and access to multiple markets through a single-entry point.

Member countries become more attractive to investors, which boosts employment, technology transfer, and capital inflow.

3. Industrial and Infrastructure Development

Integration often leads to joint infrastructure projects (like roads, railways, ports, and energy networks) and industrial cooperation.

Helps countries improve connectivity, transport efficiency, and industrial growth, especially in less developed areas.

4. Reduction in Economic Vulnerability

Smaller or developing economies are vulnerable to global shocks. Integration provides economic security by promoting regional self-reliance and market diversification.

Reduces dependence on a few trade partners and stabilizes the economy.

5. Political and Regional Cooperation

Economic integration often fosters political cooperation, peace, and diplomatic ties by increasing interdependence.

Helps resolve conflicts, build trust among neighbors, and promote regional stability.

6. Access to Technical Assistance and Capacity Building

Many regional organizations (like WTO, BIMSTEC) provide technical training, policy advice, and development funding to their members.

Enhances institutional capacity, supports economic reforms, and improves governance.

7. Boost to Competitiveness and Economic Efficiency

Integration encourages countries to become more competitive by streamlining production, adopting better standards, and reducing inefficiencies.

Leads to cheaper production costs, better product quality, and improved global competitiveness.

Joining a regional economic integration is not just about trade — it’s a comprehensive development strategy for boosting growth, strengthening institutions, and gaining a foothold in both regional and global markets.

Major Regional Economic Integrations (WTO, SAFTA, BIMSTEC, EU, ASEAN, NAFTA):

1. World Trade Organization (WTO)

The WTO is a global international organization dealing with the rules of trade between nations. Its main function is to ensure that trade flows as smoothly, predictably, and freely as possible. It is not a regional integration body but a global one that sets the framework for international trade, which regional agreements must adhere to.

• Headquarters: Geneva, Switzerland.

Principles:

• Non-discrimination:

Most-Favored-Nation (MFN): Treating all trading partners equally. If a country grants a special favor to one trading partner, it must do the same for all other WTO members.

National Treatment: Treating foreigners and locals equally. Imported and locally produced goods should be treated the same once they enter the market.

• Freer Trade: Gradually lowering trade barriers through negotiation.
• Predictability: Through binding tariffs and commitments, creating stability and transparency in trade.
• Promoting Fair Competition: Discouraging unfair practices like dumping and subsidies.
• Encouraging Development and Economic Reform: Providing special provisions for developing and least-developed countries.

Impact on Nepalese Economy:

Nepal acceded to the WTO in 2004 as the 147th member, and the first Least Developed Country (LDC) to join through full accession. This signifies Nepal's commitment to integrating into the global trading system. Nepal participates in WTO negotiations, advocating for LDC interests, such as special and differential treatment.

Positive Sides:

Access to Global Markets: WTO membership provides a predictable and stable trading environment, theoretically opening up global markets for Nepalese products and services under MFN principles.

Enhanced Credibility: Adherence to WTO rules boosts Nepal's image as a reliable trading partner, attracting foreign investment.

Dispute Settlement Mechanism: Provides a formal platform to resolve trade disputes, safeguarding Nepal's interests against unfair trade practices by larger economies.

Special and Differential Treatment: As an LDC, Nepal benefits from special provisions, including longer transition periods for implementing WTO agreements and technical assistance.

Transparency and Rule-Based System: Promotes a rules-based international trading system, reducing arbitrary trade barriers and increasing transparency in trade policies.

Policy Discipline: Encourages domestic reforms and liberalization, potentially leading to more efficient resource allocation and increased competitiveness.

Technology Transfer: Greater engagement with global markets can facilitate the transfer of technology and best practices.

Negative Sides:

Increased Competition: Domestic industries, especially small and medium enterprises (SMEs) and agriculture, face intense competition from cheaper, higher-quality imports.

Revenue Implications: Tariff reductions lead to a decrease in customs revenue, a significant source of income for Nepal.

Implementation Challenges: Complying with complex WTO agreements (e.g., Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) measures, Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT) standards) requires significant institutional and technical capacity, which Nepal often lacks.

Loss of Policy Autonomy: Limits the government's ability to protect nascent industries or provide subsidies to vulnerable sectors.

Trade Deficit Widening: Liberalization can lead to a surge in imports without a corresponding increase in exports, exacerbating the trade deficit.

Limited Export Capacity: Despite market access opportunities, Nepal's supply-side constraints (lack of infrastructure, low productivity, poor quality control) hinder its ability to fully utilize export potential.

Vulnerability to Global Shocks: Increased integration makes Nepal more susceptible to external economic downturns or trade policy changes in larger economies.

2. South Asian Free Trade Area (SAFTA)

SAFTA is a free trade agreement among the member states of the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC). It aims to reduce tariffs and non-tariff barriers to trade within the SAARC region. SAFTA and Nepal: Time for paradigm shift - The Himalayan Times - Nepal's No.1 English Daily Newspaper | Nepal News, Latest Politics, Business, World, Sports, Entertainment, Travel, Life Style News

Headquarters: SAARC Secretariat in Kathmandu, Nepal (SAFTA is a part of SAARC).

• Principles:
• Reciprocity and Mutual Advantage: Benefits should be shared fairly among members.
• Tariff Reduction: Progressive reduction and eventual elimination of tariffs on intra-regional trade.
• Non-Tariff Barrier Elimination: Addressing and removing non-tariff barriers to trade.
• Special and Differential Treatment: Providing special concessions for Least Developed Contracting States (LDCs) within the region (Bangladesh, Bhutan, Maldives, Nepal, Afghanistan).
• Transparency and Predictability: Ensuring clear and consistent trade policies.

Impact on Nepalese Economy:

Nepal is a founding member of SAARC and a signatory to SAFTA. As a landlocked LDC, Nepal seeks to leverage SAFTA for enhanced regional trade and connectivity, particularly with its large neighbors India and Bangladesh. Nepal has actively participated in SAFTA negotiations and implementation.

Positive Sides:

Preferential Market Access: Provides preferential access to markets in South Asia, especially India, Nepal's largest trading partner.

Reduced Trade Costs: Lower tariffs and efforts to reduce non-tariff barriers can reduce the cost of trade, benefiting consumers and producers.

Increased Intra-Regional Trade: Potential to boost trade within South Asia, diversifying Nepal's export basket.

Investment Opportunities: Greater regional integration can attract regional investments in various sectors.

Enhanced Regional Connectivity: SAFTA aims to improve transport and logistics within the region, which is crucial for a landlocked country like Nepal.

Poverty Alleviation: Increased trade and economic activity can contribute to job creation and poverty reduction.

Stronger Regional Identity: Fosters cooperation and understanding among South Asian nations.

Negative Sides:

Limited Implementation: SAFTA's full potential has been hampered by political tensions, particularly between India and Pakistan, leading to slow progress in trade liberalization.

Non-Tariff Barriers (NTBs): Despite agreements, NTBs (e.g., administrative hurdles, customs procedures, standards issues) remain significant challenges, particularly for Nepal's exports to India.

Rules of Origin Issues: Strict and complex rules of origin can make it difficult for Nepalese products to qualify for SAFTA preferences.

Dominance of Indian Economy: Nepal's trade with India is heavily skewed, and SAFTA might further entrench this dependence, making Nepal vulnerable to India's economic policies.

Infrastructure Deficiencies: Inadequate transport infrastructure within Nepal and across borders limits the ability to capitalize on SAFTA's benefits.

Supply-Side Constraints: Nepal's limited production capacity and lack of diversified exportable goods restrict its ability to fully utilize market access.

Informal Trade: A significant portion of trade in the region, especially between Nepal and India, remains informal, undermining the formal benefits of SAFTA.

3. Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation (BIMSTEC)

BIMSTEC is a regional organization comprising seven member states lying around the Bay of Bengal littoral and contiguous areas (Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Myanmar, Nepal, Sri Lanka, and Thailand). It aims to promote multi-sectoral technical and economic cooperation.

 

Headquarters: Dhaka, Bangladesh.

Principles:

• Voluntary and Mutually Beneficial Cooperation: Cooperation is based on the consent of members and aims for collective benefit.
• Respect for Sovereignty and Equality: All members are sovereign and equal.
• Non-interference: Respect for internal affairs of member states.
• Complementarity: Cooperation should complement, not substitute, existing bilateral and multilateral arrangements.
• Sectoral Approach: Focus on specific sectors for cooperation, such as trade, transport, energy, tourism, agriculture, and poverty alleviation.
• Impact on Nepalese Economy:

Nepal became a full member of BIMSTEC in 2004. As a landlocked country, Nepal sees BIMSTEC as a crucial platform to gain access to the sea (via Bangladesh and India), improve connectivity, and diversify its regional trade and investment partnerships beyond South Asia to include Southeast Asian economies like Myanmar and Thailand. Nepal has hosted BIMSTEC summits and plays an active role in various cooperation sectors.

Positive Sides  

1. Access to Bay of Bengal: Provides a crucial platform for Nepal to enhance its access to sea ports (via India and Bangladesh), reducing transit costs and facilitating international trade.
2. Diversification of Trade and Investment: Expands Nepal's economic partnerships beyond traditional South Asian neighbors to include dynamic Southeast Asian economies like Thailand and Myanmar, diversifying trade and investment opportunities.
3. Connectivity Projects: Focus on transport and energy connectivity projects (e.g., BIMSTEC Master Plan for Transport Connectivity, grid interconnection) directly benefits Nepal by improving infrastructure and reducing logistical bottlenecks.
4. Energy Cooperation: Significant potential for hydropower trade, with India, Bangladesh, and Bhutan, and broader energy security.
5. Tourism Development: Promotes tourism among member countries, leveraging Nepal's natural beauty and cultural heritage.
6. Knowledge Sharing and Capacity Building: Cooperation in various sectors allows for sharing of best practices, technical expertise, and capacity building.
7. Alternative to SAARC: Offers a more active and less politically constrained platform for regional cooperation compared to the often-stalled SAARC process.

Negative Sides  

1. Slow Progress on FTA: The BIMSTEC Free Trade Agreement (FTA) has been slow to materialize, limiting immediate trade benefits.
2. Implementation Challenges: Despite numerous agreements, actual implementation of projects and initiatives often faces delays due to bureaucratic hurdles and funding issues.
3. Resource Constraints: Nepal's limited financial and technical resources can hinder its effective participation and benefit from larger BIMSTEC projects.
4. Dominance of India and Thailand: The economic might of India and Thailand might lead to benefits being disproportionately skewed towards larger economies.
5. Overlapping Membership: Overlapping membership with SAARC and ASEAN can lead to duplication of efforts and diluted focus.
6. Security Concerns: Geopolitical complexities and security challenges in the Bay of Bengal region can impede cooperation.
7. Limited Public Awareness: Lack of widespread awareness about BIMSTEC's potential benefits within Nepal's business community and public.

4. European Union (EU)

A unique economic and political union of 27 member states located primarily in Europe. It has developed from a free trade area to a customs union, a common market, and an economic and monetary union, with significant political integration.

Headquarters: Brussels, Belgium (de facto administrative center); Strasbourg, France (seat of the European Parliament); Luxembourg City, Luxembourg (seat of the Court of Justice).

Principles:

·         Four Freedoms: Free movement of goods, services, capital, and people.

·         Rule of Law: All actions taken by the EU are founded on treaties and laws.

·         Democracy and Human Rights: Commitment to democratic principles, fundamental rights, and respect for human dignity.

·         Solidarity: Mutual support among member states.

·         Subsidiarity: Decisions are taken as closely as possible to the citizen.

Impact on Nepalese Economy (primarily through trade relations and development assistance, as Nepal is not a member)

Nepal has strong diplomatic and development cooperation relations with the EU. The EU is a significant development partner and a major trading partner for Nepal, particularly through the "Everything But Arms" (EBA) initiative.

Positive Sides  

·         EBA Initiative: Provides duty-free and quota-free access to the EU market for all products (except arms and ammunition) from Least Developed Countries (LDCs), including Nepal. This is a significant trade preference.

·         Major Export Destination: The EU is a crucial market for Nepalese products like carpets, textiles, pashmina, and readymade garments, benefiting thousands of Nepali producers and workers.

·         Development Assistance: The EU and its member states are significant donors to Nepal, providing aid for infrastructure, education, rural development, governance, and post-disaster reconstruction.

·         Technical Cooperation: Provides technical assistance and capacity building in areas like trade facilitation, quality standards, and intellectual property rights.

·         Investment Potential: EU companies are potential sources of foreign direct investment in Nepal.

·         Support for Democratic Transition: The EU has actively supported Nepal's peace process and democratic transition.

·         Promoting Good Governance: EU assistance often comes with conditions promoting good governance, transparency, and human rights.

Negative Sides  

·         Strict Standards and Regulations: EU's stringent product standards, phytosanitary requirements, and environmental regulations can be challenging for Nepalese exporters to meet.

·         Aviation Safety Concerns: Nepal's aviation industry has faced restrictions from the EU due to safety concerns, impacting tourism.

·         Dependency on Preferences: Over-reliance on EBA preferences can make Nepal vulnerable if the scheme is modified or withdrawn as Nepal graduates from LDC status.

·         Limited Product Diversification: Despite EBA, Nepal's export basket to the EU remains narrow, dominated by a few traditional items.

·         Bureaucratic Hurdles: Navigating EU import procedures and compliance requirements can be complex for small Nepalese businesses.

·         Global Economic Slowdown: EU's economic slowdown can impact demand for Nepalese exports.

·         Lack of Market Awareness: Nepali businesses may lack sufficient market intelligence and understanding of EU consumer preferences.

5. Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN)

A geopolitical and economic union of 10 member states in Southeast Asia. It promotes intergovernmental cooperation and facilitates economic, political, security, military, educational, and socio-cultural integration among its members and other Asian states.

Headquarters: Jakarta, Indonesia.

Principles:

Mutual Respect: For the independence, sovereignty, equality, territorial integrity, and national identity of all nations.

Non-interference: In the internal affairs of one another.

Settlement of Disputes: Renunciation of the threat or use of force, and peaceful settlement of disputes.

Effective Cooperation: Among themselves.

Regional Peace and Stability: Promotion of regional peace and stability through abiding respect for justice and the rule of law.

Impact on Nepalese Economy (through bilateral relations and regional linkages, as Nepal is not a member):

Nepal is not a member of ASEAN but engages with ASEAN member states through various bilateral and regional forums. Nepal seeks to learn from ASEAN's successful regional integration model and tap into its dynamic economies. BIMSTEC also links Nepal to some ASEAN members (Myanmar, Thailand).

Positive Sides  

Learning from Integration Model: Nepal can study ASEAN's experiences in regional integration to inform its own regional cooperation efforts.

Potential for Increased Trade and Investment: Growing economies of ASEAN members offer potential markets for Nepalese products and sources of foreign investment.

Tourism Potential: Increased connectivity with Southeast Asia can boost tourism flows to Nepal.

Technological Exchange: Opportunities for technological transfer and knowledge sharing from more advanced ASEAN economies.

People-to-People Connectivity: Enhanced cultural exchange and greater mobility of people.

Regional Stability: A stable and prosperous Southeast Asia benefits Nepal through broader Asian peace and economic dynamism.

Diverse Partnerships: Allows Nepal to forge economic partnerships beyond its immediate South Asian neighborhood.

Negative Sides  

Geographical Distance: Relative geographical distance and lack of direct land connectivity pose challenges for trade and transport.

Limited Bilateral Trade: Current trade volumes between Nepal and most ASEAN members are relatively low.

Competition from ASEAN Products: Nepalese industries may face stiff competition from efficiently produced ASEAN goods.

Visa and Connectivity Barriers: While improving, direct flights and easier visa regimes are still needed for greater interaction.

Lack of Formal Institutional Link: Nepal lacks formal institutional ties (e.g., FTA) with ASEAN as a bloc, limiting preferential access.

Focus on Bilateralism: Engagement remains largely bilateral rather than through a comprehensive regional framework.

Small Economy Disadvantage: Nepal's small economy might find it challenging to compete effectively with larger, more diversified ASEAN economies.

6. North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) / USMCA (United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement)

NAFTA was a free trade agreement between Canada, Mexico, and the United States, which came into effect in 1994. It largely eliminated tariffs and non-tariff barriers to trade and investment among the three countries. It was renegotiated and replaced by the USMCA in 2020.

Headquarters: No central headquarters; administered by national trade ministries.

Principles (of NAFTA/USMCA):

• Free Trade: Elimination of tariffs and non-tariff barriers on most goods.
• National Treatment: Treating imported goods and services no less favorably than domestic ones.
• Most-Favored-Nation (MFN): Preventing discrimination among trading partners.
• Rules of Origin: Determining which goods qualify for preferential tariff treatment.
• Intellectual Property Rights Protection: Stronger protection for intellectual property.
• Investment Protection: Providing a stable and predictable environment for investors.

Impact on Nepalese Economy (indirect, through global trade patterns and foreign aid):

Nepal is not a member of NAFTA/USMCA and does not have direct formal engagement with it as a bloc. However, the trade policies of the US, Canada, and Mexico, influenced by their regional agreement, can indirectly affect global trade patterns, foreign aid, and investment flows that might impact Nepal.

Positive Sides  

Indirect Market Access: A strong North American economy (partially driven by NAFTA/USMCA) implies strong import demand, which can indirectly benefit Nepal through global supply chains or via its trading partners.

Investment from Member States: Companies from US, Canada, and Mexico are potential sources of FDI in Nepal, though often driven by bilateral considerations rather than NAFTA/USMCA.

Learning from Trade Liberalization: Nepal can observe the outcomes and lessons from a large-scale free trade area for its own regional integration efforts.

Global Trade Rules Setting: NAFTA/USMCA often set precedents for trade rules and standards that can influence broader WTO negotiations, benefiting Nepal if they lead to overall freer global trade.

Technology and Innovation: The dynamism of North American economies can drive global innovation that eventually benefits developing countries.

Remittances: Significant Nepalese diaspora in these countries contributes to remittances, a vital source of foreign exchange.

Development Assistance: The US and Canada are significant bilateral development partners for Nepal.

Negative Sides  

1.       Trade Diversion: NAFTA/USMCA might divert trade and investment away from non-member countries like Nepal, as members prioritize trade within the bloc.

2.       Increased Competition: Goods produced within the NAFTA/USMCA region could become more competitive globally, potentially displacing Nepalese exports in third markets.

3.       No Direct: As a non-member, Nepal does not receive any preferential market access or other direct benefits from the agreement.

4.       Impact on Aid Priorities: The focus of US foreign policy and aid might shift towards its regional partners, potentially impacting aid to Nepal.

5.       Protectionist Tendencies: If the agreement leads to more protectionist stances by members against non-members, it could negatively affect global trade openness, including for Nepal.

6.       Complex Rules of Origin: The complex rules of origin in such agreements can make it difficult for products with components from outside the bloc to gain preferential access.

7.       Limited Direct Economic Linkages: Direct economic linkages between Nepal and the NAFTA/USMCA bloc are not as strong as with immediate regional partners or the EU.

Comparing SAFTA and BIMSTEC: Which gives extra privileges to Nepal? (Which one is better?)

Nepal is a member of both SAFTA (South Asian Free Trade Area) and BIMSTEC (Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation). While both aim to boost regional trade and economic cooperation, they differ in structure, benefits, and relevance to Nepal.

Key Differences Between SAFTA and BIMSTEC

Factor	SAFTA (Under SAARC)	BIMSTEC
Member Countries	8 South Asian nations (Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan, Sri Lanka)	7 nations (Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Myanmar, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Thailand)
Focus Area	Trade liberalization in South Asia	Multi-sectoral (trade, energy, transport, tourism, tech)
Trade Privileges	Preferential tariffs for LDCs (Nepal benefits)	Still evolving, but includes Thailand & Myanmar
Political Challenges	Stalled due to India-Pakistan tensions	More active (no major political conflicts)
Economic Impact	Immediate but limited (mostly India-centric)	Long-term potential (diversified markets)

 

Which One Gives Extra Privileges to Nepal?

1. Market Access & Trade Benefits

• SAFTA:
• Provides duty-free access to South Asian markets (especially India).
• Nepal gets LDC concessions, but non-tariff barriers (NTBs) limit gains.
• BIMSTEC:
• Offers access to Thailand and Myanmar, expanding beyond South Asia.
• Potential for greater trade diversification (less reliance on India).
• Verdict: BIMSTEC has more long-term potential, but SAFTA gives immediate (though limited) benefits.

2. Energy & Infrastructure Development

• SAFTA:
• Limited focus beyond trade; no major infrastructure projects.
• BIMSTEC:
• Actively promotes energy cooperation (hydropower from Nepal to India & Bangladesh).
• Plans for transport connectivity (India-Myanmar-Thailand highway).
• Verdict: BIMSTEC is better for Nepal’s hydropower and infrastructure growth.

3. Political & Diplomatic Advantages

• SAFTA:
• Stagnant due to India-Pakistan conflicts.
• SAARC summits frequently postponed.
• BIMSTEC:
• More active (no major political disputes).
• Faster decision-making (smaller group).
• Conclusion: BIMSTEC is more stable and efficient.

4. Investment & Economic Diversification

• SAFTA:
• Mostly benefits Indian-dominated trade.
• Nepal faces a huge trade deficit with India.
• BIMSTEC:
• Opens doors to Southeast Asian investment (Thailand, Myanmar).
• Potential for tourism, tech, and manufacturing growth.
• Conclusion: BIMSTEC helps reduce dependency on India.

5. Special Privileges for Nepal

• SAFTA:
• As an LDC, Nepal gets tariff concessions, but implementation is weak.
• BIMSTEC:
• No special LDC benefits yet, but Nepal can leverage hydropower & tourism.
• Conclusion: SAFTA has formal privileges, but BIMSTEC offers more strategic opportunities.

Final Conclusion: Which is Better for Nepal?

Aspect	SAFTA	BIMSTEC	Winner
Immediate Trade Benefits	✔ (India access)	❌ (Still developing)	SAFTA
Long-Term Economic Growth	❌ (Limited)	✔ (Diversified markets)	BIMSTEC
Energy & Infrastructure	❌ (Weak focus)	✔ (Hydropower, transport)	BIMSTEC
Political Stability	❌ (SAARC issues)	✔ (Smooth cooperation)	BIMSTEC
Reducing India Dependency	❌ (Increases reliance)	✔ (Links to ASEAN)	BIMSTEC

Conclusion:

• SAFTA is better for short-term trade benefits (especially with India).
• BIMSTEC is better for long-term economic diversification, energy exports, and reducing India dependency.
• Nepal should prioritize BIMSTEC while still using SAFTA for existing trade advantages.

 

• Nepal should push for faster BIMSTEC implementation (especially energy & transport projects).
• Diversify exports to Thailand & Myanmar to reduce reliance on India.
• Lobby for LDC concessions in BIMSTEC similar to SAFTA.

2.2 Government’s influence on Trade

Governments play a crucial role in shaping a country's trade landscape through a variety of policies and interventions. Their actions can significantly influence the volume, composition, and direction of international trade.

1. How Governments Influence Trade

Governments use a combination of policies, financial tools, infrastructure investment, and diplomatic agreements to either promote exports or protect local industries from excessive imports. Here's a breakdown of each area you mentioned:

A. Trade Policies & Regulations

• Tariffs & Duties

•  Governments charge taxes on imported goods.
•  To make imported products more expensive, giving local producers a competitive edge.
•  Nepal may impose duties on foreign agricultural products to protect local farmers.

• Subsidies

•  Direct or indirect financial assistance to domestic industries.
•  Helps local producers lower their costs and compete in international markets.
•  Subsidizing wool for carpet industries in Nepal.

• Quotas & Restrictions

•  Setting a maximum limit on the quantity of a product that can be imported.
•  Protects sensitive industries and avoids market flooding with cheap imports.
•  Limiting the import of foreign cement to boost Nepali manufacturers.

B. Trade Agreements & Diplomacy

• Free Trade Agreements (FTAs)

•  Bilateral or multilateral deals that reduce or eliminate tariffs between countries.
•  Boosts trade volume, lowers consumer prices, and strengthens diplomatic ties.
•  Nepal–India Trade Treaty allows duty-free access for many Nepali products in India.

• Regional Trade Blocs

•  Membership in economic groups like SAFTA, BIMSTEC, or the WTO.
•  Gain access to larger markets, technical assistance, and better negotiating power.
•  Through SAFTA, Nepal gets preferential market access to South Asian countries.

C. Infrastructure & Logistics

• Transport Networks

•  Roads, railways, airports, dry ports, and border facilities.
•  Reduces transport costs and time, making exports more competitive.
•  Nepal’s investment in dry ports like Birgunj Inland Clearance Depot (ICD).

• Special Economic Zones (SEZs)

•  Designated zones with favorable tax and regulatory policies to attract investment.
•  Encourage export-oriented industries and FDI.
•  Bhairahawa SEZ in Nepal offering tax holidays to export firms.

D. Export Promotion Measures

• Cash Incentives

•  Financial rewards such as rebates, VAT refunds, or subsidies to exporters.
•  Encourages companies to expand into international markets.
•  Nepal offers cash incentives for tea, carpets, and pashmina exporters.

• Trade Financing

•  Providing easy loans and insurance to businesses involved in exports.
•  Reduces financial risk and helps small exporters grow.
•  Nepal Rastra Bank provides refinancing at lower interest rates for export sectors.

• Brand Promotion

•  Marketing national products internationally using branding campaigns.
•  Builds reputation, demand, and premium pricing.
•  "Visit Nepal" or "Nepal Tea" campaigns.

E. Currency & Exchange Rate Management

• Devaluation

•  Reducing the value of the national currency compared to others.
•  Makes exports cheaper and more attractive abroad.
• Risk: Can lead to inflation (cost of imports rises).
•  If the Nepalese Rupee is weaker, Nepali goods become cheaper for foreign buyers.

• Forex Reserves Control

•  Managing foreign currency reserves to stabilize exchange rates.
•  Prevents drastic fluctuations which affect trade predictability.

F. Non-Tariff Barriers (NTBs) & Standards

• Quality Certifications

•  Ensuring products meet required international safety, health, or quality standards.
•  Enables smoother entry into foreign markets.
•  Organic certification for tea or herbal products from Nepal.

• Simplifying Customs

•  Streamlining import-export paperwork and reducing corruption or delays.
•  Increases efficiency and lowers transaction costs.
•  Nepal Customs Automation System and Nepal Trade Portal.

G. Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Attraction

• Tax Holidays

•  Exempting foreign investors from taxes for a certain period.
•  Encourages investment in targeted sectors like tourism, hydropower, or agro-processing.

• Ease of Doing Business

•  Reforming regulations to make starting and operating businesses simpler.
•  Attracts both domestic and foreign investment.
•  Online registration of businesses in Nepal, investment one-stop service centers.

Governments use a blend of trade policies, infrastructure investment, financial incentives, and international cooperation to influence trade. For a country like Nepal, leveraging these tools strategically can help overcome its geographic and developmental constraints and position itself as a competitive exporter in niche markets like handicrafts, tea, spices, hydropower, and tourism.

2. What is the Government of Nepal doing to Promote Export-Oriented Businesses?

 The Government of Nepal has recognized the critical need to promote exports to address its persistent and widening trade deficit, create jobs, and achieve sustainable economic growth. Nepal faces challenges like landlocked geography, weak infrastructure, and reliance on imports. However, the government has taken some major steps.

Despite being landlocked and economically constrained, Nepal has adopted a multi-dimensional strategy to strengthen its export sector. These measures aim to improve competitiveness, expand market access, and support export-oriented industries.

a) National Trade Integration Strategy (NTIS)

A comprehensive national policy launched by the Government of Nepal to guide the country's trade development efforts.

Key Features:

• Identifies Priority Export Sectors: Focuses on 12 products and 7 services with export potential, such as:
• Goods: Tea, coffee, large cardamom, woolen carpets, pashmina, ginger, handmade paper, medicinal herbs.
• Services: Information Technology (IT), tourism, health, education.
• Improves Market Access: Through branding, packaging, and product certification.
• Builds Capacity: Provides training for producers and exporters on quality standards, logistics, and compliance.

Impact:
NTIS aligns trade policy with national development goals and supports inclusive trade growth by involving small businesses and women entrepreneurs.

b) Export Subsidies and Incentives

Financial support and tax relief provided to encourage exports.

Key Programs:

• Cash Incentives: Exporters of certain goods (e.g., carpets, tea, pashmina) receive cash rebates (often 3–5% of export value) to cover production and transport costs.
• Tax Exemptions: Export earnings are often exempt from income tax or get duty drawbacks.
• Export Credit Facilities: Nepal Rastra Bank offers low-interest refinancing loans to exporters through commercial banks.

Impact:
This reduces the financial burden on exporters and makes Nepali products more competitive in foreign markets.

c) Trade Agreements

Legal agreements with other countries and regional blocs that reduce trade barriers and facilitate market access.

Nepal’s Memberships:

• World Trade Organization (WTO) – Provides most-favored-nation (MFN) status and access to global dispute resolution.
• South Asian Free Trade Area (SAFTA) – Offers duty-free/quota-free access to South Asian markets for many Nepali goods.
• BIMSTEC – Expands trade cooperation with Southeast Asian countries like Thailand and Myanmar.

Bilateral Agreements:

• India–Nepal Trade Treaty – Allows duty-free access for most Nepali exports into India.
• China–Nepal Agreement – Promotes transit access and product-specific cooperation.

Impact:
These agreements open up larger markets for Nepali products and offer Nepal favorable terms as a least developed country (LDC).

d) Trade Infrastructure

Physical and digital infrastructure to support efficient trade flows.

Key Projects:

• Integrated Check Posts (ICPs): Modern border facilities with customs, immigration, quarantine, and banking services. Major ICPs are in:
• Birgunj (India border)
• Biratnagar
• Nepalgunj
• Dry Ports (Inland Clearance Depots): Allow customs clearance away from the actual border (e.g., Birgunj ICD).
• Freight Corridors: Improve road/rail connectivity for faster goods movement to ports in India.

Impact:
Reduces border delays, improves logistics, and lowers export costs—critical for a landlocked country.

e) Nepal Trade Portal

A government-run online platform offering comprehensive trade-related information.

Key Features:

• Tariff and duty structure by product.
• Required documents for import/export.
• Step-by-step trade procedures.
• Export-import restrictions and rules.

Website: www.nepaltradeportal.gov.np

Impact:
Improves transparency, reduces corruption, and makes compliance easier—especially for new or small exporters.

f) Participation in International Fairs & Expos

The government supports Nepali businesses to attend trade fairs, exhibitions, and expos abroad.

Support:

• Subsidized booth space and promotional material.
• Coordination via the Trade and Export Promotion Centre (TEPC).
• Showcasing of “Made in Nepal” brands like:
• Nepal Tea
• Handicrafts
• Organic Spices

Impact:
These activities help Nepali exporters build relationships, secure orders, and gain global exposure for niche products.

These initiatives show that Nepal is actively working to overcome the disadvantages of being landlocked and least developed. However, challenges like political instability, poor connectivity, high logistics costs, and limited diversification of exports still need to be addressed. With continued investment in infrastructure, policy reforms, and international partnerships, Nepal can strengthen its presence in global trade.

3. Recommendations for Nepal as a Least Developed and Landlocked Country

Nepal faces unique challenges as an LDC and landlocked country. A comprehensive and sustained strategy is needed. To overcome structural disadvantages, Nepal must adopt a strategic and long-term approach to improve trade performance.

A. Diversify Export Markets

Reduce India Dependency

• Over 60% of Nepal’s trade is with India, creating vulnerability to policy changes and disruptions.
•  Expand trade relations with Bangladesh, China, the EU, the Middle East, and Southeast Asia.
• Benefit: Market diversification reduces risk and increases long-term trade stability.

Leverage BIMSTEC

• BIMSTEC includes fast-growing economies like Thailand and Myanmar.
•  Use BIMSTEC agreements to access new markets with reduced tariffs.
• Benefit: Opens doors to larger and diversified markets beyond South Asia.

B. Improve Trade Infrastructure

Upgrade Border Crossings

• Delays and inefficiencies at border points like Birgunj-Raxaul increase costs.
•  Modernize customs with digital systems, scanning machines, and fast-track lanes.
• Benefit: Faster customs clearance improves export competitiveness.

Develop Inland Waterways

• Nepal is landlocked, but access to Indian waterways (like the Ganga river system) can reduce transport costs.
•  Partner with India to develop river ports and inland transport hubs.
• Benefit: Cheaper and eco-friendly alternative to road or rail for bulk exports.

C. Enhance Export Competitiveness

Subsidize High-Value Products

• Products like organic herbs, spices, essential oils, and IT services have global demand.
•  Provide targeted subsidies and technical support to export-oriented firms.
• Benefit: Increases quality, scale, and profitability of high-margin products.

Quality Certification Labs

• Lack of certification stops many SMEs from accessing global markets.
•  Set up regional testing labs for ISO, HACCP, organic, and phytosanitary standards.
• Benefit: Helps exporters meet compliance for EU, US, and Middle East markets.

D. Strengthen SEZs & Industrial Policy

Offer Tax Breaks for 10+ Years

• Long-term incentives attract larger, export-focused investors.
•  Extend tax holidays for manufacturing, agro-processing, and IT in SEZs.
• Benefit: Encourages FDI and builds sustainable export-oriented industrial clusters.

Simplify SEZ Regulations

• Bureaucracy discourages private investment.
•  Introduce one-window clearance for all business approvals within SEZs.
• Benefit: Reduces red tape, speeds up setup, and increases investor confidence.

E. Digital Trade Facilitation

E-Customs & Paperless Trade

• Manual customs processes are slow and prone to corruption.
•  Fully digitize customs procedures (scanning, electronic documentation, tracking).
• Benefit: Enhances transparency, speeds up cross-border movement.

E-Commerce Promotion

• Digital platforms like Daraz, Amazon, Alibaba offer global reach.
•  Train SMEs on e-commerce, digital marketing, and online payments.
• Benefit: Enables even rural producers to directly export products to foreign buyers.

F. Negotiate Better Trade Deals

Lobby for LDC Benefits in WTO

• Nepal may graduate from LDC status soon, risking loss of duty-free privileges.
•  Advocate to extend trade benefits under the WTO and EU GSP+ after graduation.
• Benefit: Maintains tariff-free access for key products in major markets.

Push for Nepal–China FTA Expansion

• The current agreement is limited in product coverage and use.
•  Expand the FTA to include agro-products, handicrafts, and tourism services.
• Benefit: Opens northern markets and diversifies trade beyond the Indian dependency.

G. Focus on High-Potential Sectors

Hydropower Export

• Nepal has 83,000 MW of hydropower potential but exports only a small portion.
•  Invest in grid interconnection and regional power trade with India and Bangladesh.
• Benefit: Generates long-term revenue and diversifies exports beyond physical goods.

Tourism & Services

• Nepal offers unique tourism niches—trekking, spirituality, and medical tourism.
•  Promote packages targeting high-income tourists, including wellness and eco-tourism.
• Benefit: High foreign currency inflows, job creation, and regional branding.

To boost trade sustainably, Nepal must move beyond traditional export models and focus on diversification, infrastructure development, digital trade, and global competitiveness. These strategies can transform Nepal from a raw product exporter to a value-added, service-rich trade economy despite its structural limitations.

2.3 Role or contribution of Nepalese government in promoting global trade

The Nepalese government has been actively working to integrate Nepal into global trade through policy reforms, infrastructure development, and international partnerships. While challenges remain (like high logistics costs and political instability), these efforts are gradually improving Nepal’s position in global trade.

1. Membership in International Trade Organizations

Nepal's active participation in global trade bodies has opened up access to broader markets and provided a rules-based framework for trade.

·         WTO Membership (2004): Nepal’s accession to the World Trade Organization (WTO) marked a milestone in global trade integration. It allows Nepal to benefit from non-discriminatory trade practices, dispute resolution mechanisms, and improved transparency.

·         Nepal has also ratified the WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA), committing to reforms that streamline customs and reduce trade costs.

2. Bilateral and Multilateral Trade Agreements

The government has signed multiple bilateral and regional trade agreements to increase trade flows and reduce dependency on single markets.

·         Nepal-India Trade Treaty (Revised 2019): Ensures duty-free access to the Indian market for most Nepalese goods.

·         Nepal-China Transit Agreement (2016): Provides alternative trade routes via Chinese ports, diversifying Nepal's trade logistics.

·         US Trade and Investment Framework Agreement (TIFA, 2011): Aims to enhance economic cooperation with the U.S.

·         Membership in SAFTA and BIMSTEC fosters regional trade integration with South Asian and Southeast Asian economies.

3. Export Promotion Policies and Institutions

To increase exports, the Nepalese government has formulated dedicated policies and institutions to support producers and exporters.

·         The Trade and Export Promotion Centre (TEPC) facilitates training, market research, and participation in international trade fairs (e.g., Canton Fair, CIIE, India International Trade Fair).

·         Export incentives like cash subsidies (2–5%) and duty drawback schemes help exporters remain competitive.

4. Development of Trade Infrastructure

Physical infrastructure is critical for trade, and the government has prioritized investments to improve logistics and connectivity.

·         Development of dry ports (Birgunj, Bhairahawa) and Integrated Check Posts (ICPs) has streamlined cross-border movement of goods.

·         Upgrading Tribhuvan International Airport (TIA) and planning the Nepal-China Railway are aimed at expanding trade routes.

·         Panchkhal Industrial Estate and Special Economic Zones (SEZs) like Bhairahawa and Simara are being developed to encourage export-oriented industries.

5. Digitalization and Customs Reforms

The government has embraced digital transformation to reduce bureaucratic hurdles and modernize trade operations.

·         The implementation of the ASYCUDA (Automated System for Customs Data) World System has improved customs clearance through electronic processing.

·         Online platforms for export-import licensing and document submissions have increased transparency and reduced processing time.

6. Support for SMEs and FDI in Trade-Oriented Sectors

Recognizing that SMEs form the backbone of the economy, the government provides support through training, financing, and export facilitation.

·         The MSME Promotion Policy focuses on developing export-ready small businesses.

·         Policies under the Foreign Investment and Technology Transfer Act (FITTA) 2019 aim to attract Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), especially in export-driven sectors like hydropower, tourism, and manufacturing.

7. Product Diversification and Value Addition

To increase trade resilience, the government promotes diversification of the export basket and value-added production.

·         Focus has shifted from raw exports to processed goods such as organic tea, coffee, leather goods, and handicrafts.

·         The Nepal Trade Integration Strategy (NTIS) identifies 12–19 priority export sectors and provides specific action plans for improving competitiveness.

8. Promotion of "Made in Nepal" and International Branding

Branding is key to global trade success. The government is actively working on promoting Nepali-origin products internationally.

·         The “Made in Nepal” brand focuses on quality, authenticity, and uniqueness—especially for goods like Pashmina, carpets, silver jewelry, and medicinal herbs.

·         Certification systems and marketing support are provided to ensure global recognition and trust.

2.4 FDI Prospects and Problems in Nepal

Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) refers to investment made by foreign individuals or companies in Nepal’s businesses, industries, or infrastructure with the intention of establishing long-term control or influence.

FDI can be in the form of:

• Greenfield Investment (setting up new businesses)
• Mergers & Acquisitions (buying stakes in existing Nepalese companies)
• Joint Ventures (partnerships between foreign and Nepalese firms)

FDI is crucial for Nepal’s economic growth as it brings capital, technology, employment, and market access.

Positive Impacts of FDI in Nepal

1.      Capital Infusion and Bridging the Savings-Investment Gap:

Nepal's domestic savings are insufficient to meet its vast investment needs, particularly for large-scale infrastructure projects. FDI brings in much-needed foreign capital, directly financing projects and reducing reliance on external debt or limited domestic resources.

Investment in hydropower projects by foreign companies like NEA Engineering Company (a subsidiary of China Three Gorges Corporation) directly provides capital for dam construction and power plant development, which Nepal's budget alone cannot fully cover.

2.      Technology Transfer and Skill Development:

FDI often comes with advanced technologies, modern production methods, and managerial know-how. This leads to the transfer of knowledge and skills to the local workforce, improving productivity and competitiveness in various sectors.

Foreign investment in manufacturing units (e.g., cement factories like Hongshi Shivam Cement, a Nepal-China joint venture) introduces advanced machinery and production techniques, training local engineers and technicians in their operation and maintenance.

3.      Employment Generation:

Foreign-invested enterprises create direct employment opportunities for local populations. Indirectly, they also stimulate job creation in supporting industries, supply chains, and the service sector.

A new five-star hotel chain (e.g., Marriott, Hyatt) established through FDI not only hires local staff for its operations but also creates demand for local suppliers of food, linen, and other services, boosting ancillary employment.

4.      Export Promotion and Market Access:

Many FDI projects are export-oriented, leveraging Nepal's preferential access to markets (e.g., India, EU for LDCs). Foreign investors often have established global distribution networks, facilitated the export of Nepalese products and improved the country's trade balance.

Investment in garment or carpet manufacturing units by foreign buyers can lead to direct export of these products to international markets where the foreign investor has existing channels.

5.      Enhanced Competition and Efficiency:

The entry of foreign firms introduces competition into domestic markets, pushing local companies to improve their efficiency, product quality, and service delivery to remain competitive. This benefits consumers with more choices and better prices.

The entry of foreign telecommunication companies like Ncell (formerly Reynolds Holdings, now owned by Axiata Group Berhad) in Nepal initially spurred competition with Nepal Telecom, leading to improved services and lower tariffs for consumers.

6.      Diversification of the Economy:

FDI can help diversify Nepal's economic base by promoting growth in new or underdeveloped sectors, reducing reliance on a few traditional industries.

Investment in the IT sector, such as Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) or software development firms, can help Nepal develop a knowledge-based economy and create high-value jobs, moving beyond traditional agriculture and tourism.

7.      Fiscal Revenue Generation:

Foreign companies contribute to government revenue through corporate taxes, customs duties on imported inputs, and other levies, augmenting the national budget.

Profits earned by foreign-invested hydropower projects are subject to corporate tax in Nepal, providing a consistent revenue stream for the government.

8.      Improved Infrastructure Development:

FDI often targets infrastructure-intensive sectors like energy and transportation. Investments in these areas directly contribute to the improvement of critical infrastructure, which benefits the entire economy.

Foreign investment in large-scale hydropower projects not only generates electricity but also necessitates the construction of access roads, transmission lines, and other related infrastructure, improving overall connectivity.

Negative Impacts of FDI in Nepal

1.      Crowding Out Domestic Investment:

If foreign firms are too dominant or receive excessive incentives, they might outcompete nascent domestic industries for resources, markets, and skilled labor, potentially hindering local entrepreneurship.

If a large foreign beverage company enters Nepal with aggressive marketing and pricing strategies, smaller domestic beverage companies might struggle to compete and may even be forced out of business.

2.      Repatriation of Profits:

While FDI brings in capital, a significant portion of the profits earned by foreign companies is often repatriated to their home countries, leading to capital outflow and potentially affecting Nepal's balance of payments.

Foreign banks operating in Nepal repatriate a considerable portion of their annual profits back to their parent companies, which, while legitimate, reduces the reinvestment potential within Nepal.

3.      Environmental Degradation:

Some FDI, particularly in resource-intensive industries, can lead to environmental issues like pollution, deforestation, or over-extraction of resources if environmental regulations are weak or poorly enforced.

Unregulated foreign investment in mining or certain manufacturing processes could lead to increased air and water pollution if proper environmental impact assessments and mitigation measures are not strictly adhered to.

4.      Exploitation of Labor and Poor Working Conditions:

In pursuit of lower production costs, some foreign companies might exploit cheap labor, offer low wages, or neglect worker safety standards, especially in sectors with less stringent labor laws.

While less prevalent with reputable firms, instances of foreign-owned garment factories or construction sites failing to provide adequate safety equipment or paying below-minimum wages have been reported in various developing countries, potentially replicated in Nepal if oversight is weak.

5.      Loss of Control Over Strategic Sectors:

Heavy foreign investment in strategic sectors like telecommunications, energy, or natural resources might lead to a perceived loss of national control or influence over critical economic assets.

If a major portion of Nepal's hydropower potential is developed and controlled by foreign entities, it could raise concerns about energy security and pricing leverage, especially during times of geopolitical tension.

6.      Dependence on Foreign Technology and Inputs:

Reliance on foreign technology and capital can create technological dependence, limiting indigenous innovation and requiring continuous imports of machinery, spare parts, and expertise.

If a foreign-owned electronics assembly plant relies entirely on imported components and sophisticated machinery, Nepal might not develop its own capacity for innovation or component production.

7.      Cultural and Social Impact:

The introduction of foreign business practices and consumption patterns can sometimes lead to cultural changes, potentially eroding local traditions or promoting consumerism.

The proliferation of foreign fast-food chains or large retail brands, while offering convenience, might alter local dietary habits or negatively impact traditional small businesses and local food culture.

8.      Vulnerability to Global Economic Shocks:

Economies heavily reliant on FDI can become more vulnerable to global economic downturns or changes in investment sentiment, leading to sudden capital withdrawals or reduced new investments.

During the global financial crisis of 2008 or the recent COVID-19 pandemic, many multinational corporations scaled back their international investments, leading to a decline in FDI inflows even to developing countries like Nepal.

Current Trend of FDI in Nepal:

The trend of FDI in Nepal has been characterized by fluctuations, with commitments often significantly higher than actual inflows, reflecting the gap between policy intent and ground realities.

1.      Rising FDI Commitments but Modest Actual Inflows: Nepal has seen a recent surge in FDI commitments, with pledges increasing by about 33% in the first ten months of the current fiscal year (ending mid-May), reaching around Rs 56.78 billion. However, actual inflows remain much lower, with only Rs 8.96 billion in equity received during the first nine months of the current fiscal year. This disparity is a persistent challenge.

2.      Focus on Small-Scale Projects: Most of the recent FDI commitments, particularly those approved through the automatic route, are directed towards small-scale industries. For instance, Rs 45.44 billion was pledged for 551 small-scale projects.

3.      Dominance of Service and Tourism Sectors in Commitments: The service sector (Rs 29.98 billion) and tourism sector (Rs 20 billion) have received the highest amounts of FDI commitments in the current fiscal year, indicating investor interest in these areas.

4.      Hydropower and Manufacturing Still Key Drivers: Historically and currently, sectors like hydropower and manufacturing continue to attract substantial FDI. China, for instance, has been a major investor in Nepal's hydropower sector.

5.      Impact of Policy Reforms: Recent amendments to FDI-related laws, including the Foreign Investment and Technology Transfer Act (FITTA) and a more streamlined approval process, are cited as primary reasons for the increase in FDI commitments.

6.      China as a Leading Investor: Recent Nepal Rastra Bank reports indicate that China has surpassed India as the largest investor in Nepal, particularly in hydropower and manufacturing.

7.      Increase in Automatic Route Registrations: There has been a notable increase in FDI pledges through the automatic route, indicating a simplified initial registration process for certain types of investments.

8.      Persistent Gap Between Pledges and Realization: The discrepancy between approved FDI (intent to invest) and net FDI inflow (actual investment minus repatriation) remains significant. This gap is partly due to the phased nature of investments and time lags between approval and fund disbursement.

Why FDI Not According to Expectation:

Despite Nepal's potential and policy reforms, FDI inflows have consistently fallen short of expectations.

1.      Political Instability and Policy Inconsistency:

Frequent changes in government and political leadership lead to a lack of long-term policy coherence and predictability, making investors hesitant to commit large capital.

The frequent changes in the Industrial Policy or tax regimes with each new government can create uncertainty for foreign investors, who require a stable regulatory environment for their long-term projects.

2.      Bureaucratic Hurdles and Procedural Complexities:

Despite efforts like the Single Window System, investors often face lengthy, multi-layered approval processes, excessive documentation requirements, and a lack of inter-agency coordination.

An investor might need to submit the same documents to the Department of Industry, Nepal Rastra Bank, and other ministries, leading to significant delays and increased transaction costs. The full implementation of the Single Window System is still pending.

3.      Inadequate Infrastructure:

Poor quality and insufficient infrastructure, especially unreliable electricity supply (load shedding), inadequate transport networks, and limited access to quality internet, significantly raise operational costs for businesses.

A manufacturing company considering setting up a plant in Nepal might be deterred by the high cost of operating on diesel generators due to erratic power supply, or by the slow and expensive logistics due to poor road conditions.

4.      Difficulties in Repatriation of Profits:

While streamlined, the process for repatriating profits and dividends still involves approvals from multiple government agencies, leading to delays and frustration for foreign investors.

Foreign companies have reported delays in getting approvals from Nepal Rastra Bank and other departments for repatriating their earnings, which discourages further investment.

5.      Stringent Labor Laws and Shortage of Skilled Labor:

Nepal's labor laws are often perceived as rigid, making it difficult for companies to adjust their workforce based on market demands. Additionally, there is a shortage of highly skilled and technically trained labor.

A foreign investor might find it challenging to hire specialized engineers or technicians locally, or face difficulties in adjusting staff numbers due to complex labor union regulations, increasing operational inflexibility.

6.      Corruption and Lack of Transparency:

Corruption at various levels of bureaucracy increases uncertainty, inflates transaction costs, and erodes trust in public institutions, making Nepal a less attractive destination.

Investors have reported instances of unofficial payments being required to expedite approvals or processes, which adds to the cost of doing business and creates a non-transparent environment.

7.      Limited Access to Financing and High Cost of Doing Business:

While FDI brings capital, foreign investors sometimes require local financing for working capital or expansion, which can be difficult to obtain or come at high interest rates. Overall, the cost of various operational aspects can be higher than in competing economies.

Limits on foreign borrowings or the high interest rates charged by Nepali banks for certain sectors might make it less appealing for foreign firms to leverage local financial markets.

8.      Land Acquisition Issues:

Acquiring land for large-scale projects can be a significant hurdle due to complex ownership structures, lengthy legal processes, and resistance from local communities.

Several large-scale infrastructure and industrial projects, even those with committed FDI, have faced delays or abandonment due to protracted land acquisition disputes and difficulties.

How to Encourage FDI (Recommendations to Nepal Government):

To enhance FDI inflows, the Nepal government needs a comprehensive and sustained approach focusing on policy consistency, institutional reforms, and investor facilitation.

1.      Ensure Political Stability and Policy Predictability:

Develop a national consensus on key economic policies and a long-term vision for FDI, transcending short-term political cycles. Enact and strictly adhere to stable, transparent, and consistent laws and regulations.

A stable political environment will reduce uncertainty for investors, making them more confident in committing long-term capital. This means fewer abrupt changes in tax policies, investment thresholds, or sector-specific regulations.

2.      Expedite and Simplify Investment Approval and Operation Processes:

Fully implement the "Single Window Service Center" with all relevant agencies physically present or digitally integrated. Streamline all licensing, registration, and operational permits, making them time-bound and digitally accessible.

Reducing bureaucratic red tape and creating a truly one-stop shop for investors will significantly cut down on time and cost, making Nepal more competitive. This includes automating processes for industry registration, tax payment, and profit repatriation.

3.      Invest Heavily in Infrastructure Development:

Prioritize investment in critical infrastructure, particularly reliable electricity supply, improved road and air connectivity, and modern communication networks. Explore public-private partnerships (PPPs) for faster development.

Reliable power, efficient transport, and robust communication are fundamental for any business. Addressing these bottlenecks will reduce operational costs for foreign investors and improve overall productivity.

4.      Strengthen Legal and Regulatory Frameworks and Enforcement:

Ensure the effective and impartial enforcement of contracts, property rights, and commercial laws. Improve the judicial system to resolve commercial disputes efficiently and transparently. Consider developing specialized commercial courts.

A strong, predictable, and fair legal system builds investor confidence by assuring them that their investments are protected and disputes can be resolved equitably.

5.      Address Labor Market Rigidities and Enhance Skill Development:

Reform labor laws to introduce greater flexibility while protecting workers' rights. Simultaneously, invest in vocational training and skill development programs to create a pool of qualified labor that meets the demands of modern industries.

Flexible labor laws can attract manufacturing and service-based FDI, while a skilled workforce reduces training costs for foreign firms and enhances productivity.

6.      Combat Corruption and Enhance Transparency:

Implement robust anti-corruption measures, promote transparency in all government dealings related to investment, and strengthen oversight mechanisms. Foster a culture of integrity within the bureaucracy.

Corruption is a significant deterrent to FDI. A transparent and corruption-free environment reduces hidden costs and risks for investors, making Nepal a more attractive and ethical investment destination.

7.      Offer Targeted Incentives and Investment Promotion:

Develop sector-specific incentives for priority areas (e.g., hydropower, tourism, IT, export-oriented industries) that go beyond general tax breaks and include support for infrastructure linkages, market access, and skill development. Actively promote Nepal's investment opportunities through international roadshows and investment summits, focusing on success stories.

Tailored incentives can attract specific types of FDI that align with Nepal's development goals. Proactive promotion helps to inform potential investors about the opportunities and reforms being undertaken.

FDI has significant potential to transform Nepal’s economy by bringing in capital, technology, and employment. However, policy inconsistency, infrastructure gaps, and bureaucratic hurdles have prevented Nepal from realizing its full FDI potential. A coordinated approach involving reforms, promotion, and long-term planning is essential for attracting and sustaining high-quality foreign investments.

 

 

Top of Form